Friday, September 28, 2012

Don't Believe You Haze? Change Your Perspective And Look Again




Sometimes we laugh, albeit to ourselves, when sorority and fraternity members tell us hazing doesn’t exist in their chapter or community.  It’s not that we think they’re lying; we know they believe it and respect their opinion, even though we usually disagree.

And look, we know hazing isn’t funny either.  What’s funny is the way we as so vehemently deny the plausibility of something’s existence that we feel the effects of every day.  Ever had a potential new member they don’t think they have time for your organization?  In part, that’s shaped by the reality created by pledging and new member programs that inappropriately prioritize their time or require them to do things are unrelated to their organization’s actual purpose.

And to clarify, when we laugh, it’s not because the situation is haha funny.  It’s because we’re nervous.  Nervous that our organizations aren’t going to wake up and see the writing on the wall:  If we don’t find ways to positively build men and women without hazing them, eventually we will become irrelevant.

In a way, people need to start treating hazing just a little bit more like the wind.  Just because you can’t technically see it, doesn’t mean it’s not there.  When the wind blows, you can still see what it does, how things in its path are affected by it.  Hazing is the same way.  Take fraternity lineups or referring to sorority new members as babies.  We might not see a problem with those things, yet they shape the way the culture views and treats the new members.  They encourage members to adopt an identity that may be harmful, immature or intolerant.  We might not see a problem, but we certainly can feel it’s effects.

So, how do we see the wind?  Change our perspective.  Scientists use tons of theories and gadgets to better measure, track and understand patterns in the weather.  It’s time we started to take a similar approach.  To actually prevent hazing, we have to change the way we’re looking for it. 

At the FVS, we love theory.  So, we figured we’d take a quick look at some prevention theories used by the health industry and offer them as different lenses from which to examine your theory or community.

Perspective #1:  The absence of signs and symptoms of hazing indicates healthy member development

This is the most commonly used perspective, in our opinion.  The problem is, we have a hard time even identifying what our signs and symptoms are.  In addition, the absence of negative approaches does not necessarily connote a positive approach is in place.  When assuming this perspective, be aware of it’s limitations, but take the time to see if you can identify actual problems or issues that indicate your chapter or community is negatively shaping its members.

Perspective #2:  The health of an organization is indicated by its members’ abilities to perform their roles

Do you have officers that aren’t doing their jobs?  There’s a strong chance that this behavior is being reinforced when they are trained to be members.  Refocus your member education programs to include training on how to prioritize in college, manage multiple time commitments and treat organizational roles professionally.  Eliminate any training that distracts members from doing their duties or encourages them to waste their time.

Perspective #3:  A healthy organizations adapts to change

How easily does your membership ebb and flow with changes made in your chapter or community?  If a chapter perseveres through change and welcomes it, there’s a chance their membership is accustomed to critical thinking, maintaining a positive image through conflict and teamwork.  If not, it’s possible you’re actually training your members to too heavily embrace tradition and constancy, as well as only do as their told.

Perspective #4:  Organizational health is represented by an ongoing process toward its highest potential

If an activity doesn’t foster a benefit of the overall organization, why do it?  It’s time we started looking at member education as an ongoing process of constant improvement.  If something you do doesn’t improve an organizational need, it may be the case it should be eliminated.

Perspective #5:  Poor environmental conditions indicate poor health

Are your members often prone to argue or fight, rather than work together?  Are people apathetic, disengaged or motivated for the wrong reasons?  The physical, mental and emotional environment of your chapter or community matters, and may be reflective of hazing.

Remember, when asking yourself how to prevent hazing and the negative practices that go with it, it’s often best to approach the problem from different angles.

Wednesday, September 26, 2012

We Should Treat Hazing Like Our Health (Part 1/2 of Hazing Prevention Week Series)




In our world, we love schedules.  We have calendars for our personal lives, organizational events, member education programs, and campus activities.  And on those individual calendars, we place important stuff like our friends’ birthdays or our next vacation.  Heck, we even have digital schedules that help us keep track of when we’re recording our favorite TV shows. 

And for those responsible folks out there, those same personal calendars should include at least one doctor’s visit. At minimum, the annual checkup should be on there.  We might even have a specialty doctor or two we need to visit.  We’re supposed to go to these people, especially when we don’t think we’re sick. 

The assumptions are that we’re not qualified with what lack of medical training most of us have and that it’s very difficult to diagnose yourself accurately.  And from where we sit, we think those assumptions are pretty spot on.

So, why then, do we try to self-diagnose our chapter’s or community’s health by ourselves?  When’s the last time you’ve seen a Membership Development and Training Checkup on your schedule?  And even if you had one, who would you scheduled with?

Bottom line:  We spend a lot of time talking about hazing like a disease we don’t understand.  And that’s because we don’t.  Most of us don’t understand the long-term psychological and sometimes physiological effects of compelling someone through force, coercion, manipulation, or a jaded sense of belonging.  But most of us know what it’s like to feel mental, verbal, and physical stress.  And most of us have enough common sense to know that inflicting it on others is wrong.

And when we know something is wrong but we don’t know what to do about it, we ask for another opinion. Or at least, we should, like going to the doctor. 

And there tons of people out there we could easily ask to help us do some preventative maintenance on the way we educate our new members.  Headquarters staffs, alumni advisory boards, campus-based fraternity and sorority advisors, university counseling staff, and even the local police departments  can help you make preventative plans and better understand what you should and should not be doing. 

But it’s up to you to ask.  You have to put it on your schedule.

We’re not talking in metaphors anymore.  This is too important.  Go to your chapter schedule right now and pencil in a time in the next week when you’re going to sit down and discuss your chapter’s traditions, new member education practices, and regular events with someone.  Let them know beforehand that there may be cause for concern, and you trust them to evaluate your chapter discreetly. 

Now, due to legal issues, not every one of those resources can do that, but most can speak with you very generally about what is and what is not okay.  Keep in mind, just because you think a particular practice is a nonissue, doesn’t mean it is.  Look for symptoms:  Inability to retain new members, in-fighting and a significant amount of your new members struggling with personal issues.  These can all be reflective of a much larger disease.

As a disclaimer, keep in mind that the main difference between disease prevention and hazing prevention lies in training.  Even though we trust that most alumni advisors should be able to help you do the right thing, we know the reality is that some won’t.  And, admittedly, some HQ staffs or local professionals don’t get it either.  That’s ok.  If you feel like you need a second opinion, reach out and get as many as you need.

And, after scheduling these types of preventative discussions once, don’t be afraid to do it again and build it into your organizational routine.  We often hold officer transition retreats and recruitment planning meetings like clockwork.  Why are we not doing the same thing to proactively address the way we shape and mold our members, for better or worse?

Oh, and as part of the AFLV’s LeaderLink Partnership with HazingPrevention.Org you could also attend this webinar, tomorrow. 

It’s time to take the first step and making prevention a priority.

Monday, September 17, 2012

We Owe You One, Jeff Kirshman




A little over a week ago, a sports editor named Jeff at The Daily Illini did something that every sorority and fraternity member loves to hate: He, like many collegiate journalists, wrote an article detailing his experience with fraternity parties during recruitment.

Like many articles out there, his piece is peppered with what he heard, saw, and felt as he walked from chapter house to chapter house. Sure, at times his depiction is flavored by his own experience and biased by the lenses of his own personal values. What perception isn’t?

But Jeff in particular took the time to call out those organizations that think that alcohol consumption, popularity posturing, and masculine grandstanding are key elements of the fraternity experience. Just by writing comments verbatim and sharing them with the rest of us, he reveals several nasty but overly common paradigms that permeate our fraternal experiences.

Admit it folks, we’ve got more issues than Charlie Sheen on a late night party binge. Look deeply at some of the things Jeff said he saw out there. Where in you ritual does your organization advocate behavior like that? Love. Truth. Honor. Family. His article blatantly points out behavior that runs completely contrary to these core values commonly found in each of our Rituals.

And that’s not ok.

And attacking Jeff for pointing it out isn’t okay, either.  Jeff, and the people like him who call us out when we don’t do what our core values suggest we should, serve a critical purpose in the positive development of our organizations: they help us see the issues we often can’t from the inside.

It’s time we started blowing our own whistles rather than leaving it only to people like Jeff and Mary to call us out. Get organized. Find people like you who are ready to be values-based dissenters. Arm yourself with educational tools to help your members better understand why behaviors that contradict our core values need to change. Reach out to professionals and alumni who can help prepare you with the resources to make the change. Write articles and have conversations that recognize members who are doing the right things and respectfully challenge those who aren’t.

Or, just start a chapter of the Fraternal Values Society. It’s what we do. Either way, we think you’re moving in the right direction.
­­

Monday, September 10, 2012

If You're Too Busy For This, You're Too Busy



This week, we’re calling out the cheese balls who write clichés, specifically the dunce who coined the old line, “Absence makes the heart grow fonder.”  You probably get the gist: If you’re not around someone for a significant period of time, you’ll realize just how much they mean to you. Admittedly, we concede that even we have been in situations that make this feel true.

But in the context of sorority and fraternity life, living this mantra is just plain cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs.

As school begins, sorority and fraternity members often get so caught up in our own worlds: tests, to-do lists, work, student organizations, chapter meetings, events, boyfriends and girlfriends that they unknowingly start to abandon their own brothers and sisters at arguably the most vulnerable and stressful transition they’ll experience all year.

As our brothers and sisters fail to show up for late night coffee, movie nights, and chapter dinners, they’ll soon find themselves lamenting that they’d like to just hang out, but they simply don’t have time. And when they have an opportunity to help reach out and truly change a life, odds are they’ll probably miss it. Or worse, they’ll need help, and may feel too disconnected to ask for it. 

In today’s world, the chance that you could miss out on an opportunity to help a friend though depression, a bad breakup, academic troubles or a death in the family is pretty high.  Do you really want your sisters and brothers to face that kind of stuff alone? 

Wake up and smell the garbanzo beans. We like to say that our organizations stand for sisterhood and brotherhood, but more often than not, we see treat our membership like the Girl/Boy Scouts:  Earn as many merit badges in a 4 year period in a mad race to stretch ourselves thin and burn ourselves out.  Sacrifice relationships as needed.  Rinse.  Repeat.

And it’s no big deal that we treat ourselves like this, because we already have brotherhood/sisterhood night once a week. That solves everything, right?

Wrong. A recent twist to an old adage perhaps says it best: The grass is only greener when you water it.  Forcing your members to spend quality time with one another is flawed.  They have to want it.

Don’t be afraid to take the structure out of the situation and empower your individual members to connect. Cancel a meeting, buy some coffee and donuts, and spend some real quality time listening to each other. If you hear the distress in a member’s voice that indicates he or she needs to talk, take some extra time to sit down with them or arrange a time that works for both of you. Build a time for members to sit down and talk one-on-one into the beginning or end of your meetings.  Just be cool and let people connect at their own pace.

Or here’s a radical thought: Set an expectation and model the way for your new members that if a member needs help, it’s your duty to spend some time listening to him or her.  How many new member ed programs model and highlight that?  We tend to think it’s a bit more important than knowing your Greek alphabet, but that’s just us.

The cultivation of an authentic sense of belonging and friendship is an obligation of membership in our organizations. If you don’t believe us, read your Ritual.  We have a feeling it’s in there.

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

10 Ways We Help Our New Members Fail



It’s that time of year again. You’re busting your butt out there making fliers, sending emails, calling potential new members, and asking people you trust to recommend new people for membership. There are a lot of things to do, places to go, and people to meet. It’s an exciting time.
And it should be. Your organization is growing. Soon, these folks who didn’t know who your founders are or your organization's symbol will be setting out on the journey that is sisterhood and brotherhood. They’ll be quizzed, lectured, learn your chants and songs. By simply modeling it, you’ll probably teach them the sorority squat and the bro hug. You know, all the important stuff.

And then, shortly thereafter, you’ll help them fail. Out of the fraternity or sorority. Out of the university or their degree programs. At the development of their own social and creative skills. Like a seasoned machine, you’ll shoot down their hopes, dreams, and aspirations faster than you can say “Bogey on your six.”

The worst part is, most of the time, you won’t even be able to identify what you and the rest of your brothers and sisters did to contribute to the suck. Heck, if you do what most of us here at the FVS did, you’ll probably just sit around at members-only meetings and fish for reasons that your new members’ failures were all their fault.
“He just didn’t study enough to pass his classes.”
 “She partied too much.”
 “He hung out too much with his friends from high school and didn’t bond with his brothers.”
“She didn't have the money to move into the sorority house.”

And, after alleviating yourselves from any responsibility to your new members’ well-being, your chapter will probably start talking about how happy you are that the rest of your new members are quality peeps. But as those folks dwindle down, burn out, resign, or just simply fade into apathetic nonexistence, all of the things you’ve told yourself to feel better won’t sound all that grand any more.

If you’re skeptical, crunch the numbers. Look at your organization’s retention of new members in the first year. Then the second. Then over the past four years. We had some of our staff do it for the sheer joy of transparency. Here’s what we came up with:

·      One fraternity member started in a class of 26 new members. 11 of those initiated within the first two years. Only 5 of them are still members today. Over 4 years, that’s 19% retention. It’s worth noting the chapter eventually closed due to declining membership.
·      One sorority member started in a class of 20 new members. Only 8 of them are still members today. That’s 40% retention. Not so hot.
·      Another fraternity member started with 60 new members. Only 15 of them are still members today. That’s 25% retention. Yikes.
And these are examples of chapters that gave people such a profound life experience they chose to devote their careers to the pursuit of fraternity and sorority development!  All of these retention rates are abysmal for organizations who claim to be developing young men and women into lifelong members and valued servants of their communities. We realize our evidence is not an accurate sample, but our experiences as well as those communicated to us by FVS members nationwide seem to suggest that this trend isn’t going away. It might even be getting worse.

But at the FVS, we like to do more than just talk. We like to confront the brutal facts, Jim Collins style (Read Good to Great today, if you haven’t already) and then provide tools to make change happen.

With that, we’d like to present our list of …. drum roll, please:

10 Things We Do To Help Our New Members Fail

10) We recruit the wrong people.
We’re hoping this first one gets you a little fired up. Although we’re all about Elevatism, you can’t make people into something they’re not. Although our chapters work hard to find the best people for their organizations, the vast majority is not meeting enough potential new members to select a sustainable amount of quality men and woman or defining the standards for membership. Wondering why that new member is drunk and rude at all of your functions? Chances are, you saw the same behavior while recruiting them and rewarded them for it, thinking they were cool. Get to know your potential new members and make smart decisions about whether or not to extend them bids of membership. It is perfectly okay to say no and move on to someone else.

9) We immediately draw the line between ‘us’ and ‘them.’
If you extend someone a bid for membership, that should be it; they are a member of the chapter. New members should prove themselves through their day-to-day behaviors, their ability to incorporate our values into their decision making, and the overall quality of their character. If our new members are doing that, and we still feel like our active membership is significantly different, we need to take a look in the mirror.

8) We don’t say we’re sorry.
Whoever determined that member meant ‘omnipotent’ and new member meant ‘wrong’ was sorely mistaken. To develop actual trust with new members, you’ll have to admit when you or your chapter has made a mistake. Own it. They’ll respect you for it later.

7) We suck at providing a good product.
If you've ever had your car washed or gotten a cup of coffee, you know the value of good service. We need to step up and recognize that we as fraternal organizations are developmental service providers. People don’t buy crappy products, and people don’t stay members of organizations that don’t make them better.

6) We lie.
This one seems so simple, but we are so guilty of it. And we often tell new members to expect things that we don’t provide. It’s not because we intend to lie but because we don’t even know our own chapter well enough to know what we provide.

5) We don’t invest in them.
Listen. Engage. Make your new members just as important as you would your best friends in your organization. It’s not their duty to come to you. They’re new and learning the ropes. You know what your organization is about. Share it with them.

4) We focus on their memories instead of their minds.
How many member ed programs do you know require rote memorization of specific words, phrases or historical info? How many of you provoke engaging conversation and critical discussion about the purpose of our organizations?

3) We reward having their priorities out of whack.
Ever slapped a guilt trip on a new member for skipping an organizational function to study? We have. And we've also watched several new members learn over time to set the wrong priorities for their time.

2) We set bad examples.
Your behavior is the loudest message of “who we are,” and it’s the strongest impression that sets up your new members’ experiences in the organization. Be mindful of how you share negativity and positivity through your actions. Both attitudes are contagious.

1) We didn’t share our values with them.
This one sounds similar to #2, but it has a unique additional component: understanding why. Sit down with your new members and discuss the “why” of  your members’ actions and how those individual actions relate to the organization’s Ritual. Don’t worry about saying certain words you’re not supposed to. Be open, honest, genuine, and vulnerable.

So there you have it. We strongly recommend that you don’t hide these. Let them drive a conversation about the culture of your chapter. Post the list in your meeting room. Send it out to all of your members. Tape it to your best friend’s door. But use it to critically evaluate what you’re doing to enable unnecessary struggle and conflict within your new members. ­­