Friday, September 28, 2012

Don't Believe You Haze? Change Your Perspective And Look Again




Sometimes we laugh, albeit to ourselves, when sorority and fraternity members tell us hazing doesn’t exist in their chapter or community.  It’s not that we think they’re lying; we know they believe it and respect their opinion, even though we usually disagree.

And look, we know hazing isn’t funny either.  What’s funny is the way we as so vehemently deny the plausibility of something’s existence that we feel the effects of every day.  Ever had a potential new member they don’t think they have time for your organization?  In part, that’s shaped by the reality created by pledging and new member programs that inappropriately prioritize their time or require them to do things are unrelated to their organization’s actual purpose.

And to clarify, when we laugh, it’s not because the situation is haha funny.  It’s because we’re nervous.  Nervous that our organizations aren’t going to wake up and see the writing on the wall:  If we don’t find ways to positively build men and women without hazing them, eventually we will become irrelevant.

In a way, people need to start treating hazing just a little bit more like the wind.  Just because you can’t technically see it, doesn’t mean it’s not there.  When the wind blows, you can still see what it does, how things in its path are affected by it.  Hazing is the same way.  Take fraternity lineups or referring to sorority new members as babies.  We might not see a problem with those things, yet they shape the way the culture views and treats the new members.  They encourage members to adopt an identity that may be harmful, immature or intolerant.  We might not see a problem, but we certainly can feel it’s effects.

So, how do we see the wind?  Change our perspective.  Scientists use tons of theories and gadgets to better measure, track and understand patterns in the weather.  It’s time we started to take a similar approach.  To actually prevent hazing, we have to change the way we’re looking for it. 

At the FVS, we love theory.  So, we figured we’d take a quick look at some prevention theories used by the health industry and offer them as different lenses from which to examine your theory or community.

Perspective #1:  The absence of signs and symptoms of hazing indicates healthy member development

This is the most commonly used perspective, in our opinion.  The problem is, we have a hard time even identifying what our signs and symptoms are.  In addition, the absence of negative approaches does not necessarily connote a positive approach is in place.  When assuming this perspective, be aware of it’s limitations, but take the time to see if you can identify actual problems or issues that indicate your chapter or community is negatively shaping its members.

Perspective #2:  The health of an organization is indicated by its members’ abilities to perform their roles

Do you have officers that aren’t doing their jobs?  There’s a strong chance that this behavior is being reinforced when they are trained to be members.  Refocus your member education programs to include training on how to prioritize in college, manage multiple time commitments and treat organizational roles professionally.  Eliminate any training that distracts members from doing their duties or encourages them to waste their time.

Perspective #3:  A healthy organizations adapts to change

How easily does your membership ebb and flow with changes made in your chapter or community?  If a chapter perseveres through change and welcomes it, there’s a chance their membership is accustomed to critical thinking, maintaining a positive image through conflict and teamwork.  If not, it’s possible you’re actually training your members to too heavily embrace tradition and constancy, as well as only do as their told.

Perspective #4:  Organizational health is represented by an ongoing process toward its highest potential

If an activity doesn’t foster a benefit of the overall organization, why do it?  It’s time we started looking at member education as an ongoing process of constant improvement.  If something you do doesn’t improve an organizational need, it may be the case it should be eliminated.

Perspective #5:  Poor environmental conditions indicate poor health

Are your members often prone to argue or fight, rather than work together?  Are people apathetic, disengaged or motivated for the wrong reasons?  The physical, mental and emotional environment of your chapter or community matters, and may be reflective of hazing.

Remember, when asking yourself how to prevent hazing and the negative practices that go with it, it’s often best to approach the problem from different angles.

No comments:

Post a Comment