It’s that time of year again. You’re busting your
butt out there making fliers, sending emails, calling potential new members, and asking
people you trust to recommend new people for membership. There are a lot of
things to do, places to go, and people to meet. It’s an exciting time.
And it should be. Your organization is growing. Soon, these
folks who didn’t know who your founders are or your organization's symbol will be setting out on the journey that is sisterhood and
brotherhood. They’ll be quizzed, lectured, learn your chants and songs.
By simply modeling it, you’ll probably teach them the sorority squat and the
bro hug. You know, all the important stuff.And then, shortly thereafter, you’ll help them fail. Out of the fraternity or sorority. Out of the university or their degree programs. At the development of their own social and creative skills. Like a seasoned machine, you’ll shoot down their hopes, dreams, and aspirations faster than you can say “Bogey on your six.”
The worst part is, most of the time, you won’t even be able to identify what you and the rest of your brothers and sisters did to contribute to the suck. Heck, if you do what most of us here at the FVS did, you’ll probably just sit around at members-only meetings and fish for reasons that your new members’ failures were all their fault.
“He just didn’t study enough to pass his classes.”
“She partied too much.”
“He hung out too much with his friends from high school and didn’t bond with his brothers.”
“She didn't have the money to move into the sorority house.”
And, after alleviating yourselves from any responsibility to your new members’ well-being, your chapter will probably start talking about how happy you are that the rest of your new members are quality peeps. But as those folks dwindle down, burn out, resign, or just simply fade into apathetic nonexistence, all of the things you’ve told yourself to feel better won’t sound all that grand any more.
If you’re skeptical, crunch the numbers. Look at your organization’s retention of new members in the first year. Then the second. Then over the past four years. We had some of our staff do it for the sheer joy of transparency. Here’s what we came up with:
· One fraternity member started in a class of 26
new members. 11 of those initiated within the first two years. Only 5 of them are still members today. Over
4 years, that’s 19% retention. It’s worth noting the chapter eventually
closed due to declining membership.
· One sorority member started in a class of 20 new
members. Only 8 of them are still members today. That’s 40% retention. Not so
hot.
· Another fraternity member started with 60 new
members. Only 15 of them are still members today. That’s 25% retention. Yikes.
And these are examples of chapters that gave people such a
profound life experience they chose to devote their careers to the pursuit of
fraternity and sorority development! All
of these retention rates are abysmal for organizations who claim to be
developing young men and women into lifelong members and valued servants of
their communities. We realize our evidence is not an accurate sample, but our
experiences as well as those communicated to us by FVS members nationwide seem
to suggest that this trend isn’t going away. It might even be getting worse.But at the FVS, we like to do more than just talk. We like to confront the brutal facts, Jim Collins style (Read Good to Great today, if you haven’t already) and then provide tools to make change happen.
With that, we’d like to present our list of …. drum roll, please:
10 Things We Do To Help Our New Members Fail
10) We recruit the
wrong people.
We’re hoping this first one gets you a little fired up. Although we’re all about Elevatism, you can’t make people into something they’re not. Although our chapters work hard to find the best people for their organizations, the vast majority is not meeting enough potential new members to select a sustainable amount of quality men and woman or defining the standards for membership. Wondering why that new member is drunk and rude at all of your functions? Chances are, you saw the same behavior while recruiting them and rewarded them for it, thinking they were cool. Get to know your potential new members and make smart decisions about whether or not to extend them bids of membership. It is perfectly okay to say no and move on to someone else.
We’re hoping this first one gets you a little fired up. Although we’re all about Elevatism, you can’t make people into something they’re not. Although our chapters work hard to find the best people for their organizations, the vast majority is not meeting enough potential new members to select a sustainable amount of quality men and woman or defining the standards for membership. Wondering why that new member is drunk and rude at all of your functions? Chances are, you saw the same behavior while recruiting them and rewarded them for it, thinking they were cool. Get to know your potential new members and make smart decisions about whether or not to extend them bids of membership. It is perfectly okay to say no and move on to someone else.
9) We immediately
draw the line between ‘us’ and ‘them.’
If you extend someone a bid for membership, that should be it; they are a member of the chapter. New members should prove themselves through their day-to-day behaviors, their ability to incorporate our values into their decision making, and the overall quality of their character. If our new members are doing that, and we still feel like our active membership is significantly different, we need to take a look in the mirror.
If you extend someone a bid for membership, that should be it; they are a member of the chapter. New members should prove themselves through their day-to-day behaviors, their ability to incorporate our values into their decision making, and the overall quality of their character. If our new members are doing that, and we still feel like our active membership is significantly different, we need to take a look in the mirror.
8) We don’t say we’re
sorry.
Whoever determined that member meant ‘omnipotent’ and new member meant ‘wrong’ was sorely mistaken. To develop actual trust with new members, you’ll have to admit when you or your chapter has made a mistake. Own it. They’ll respect you for it later.
Whoever determined that member meant ‘omnipotent’ and new member meant ‘wrong’ was sorely mistaken. To develop actual trust with new members, you’ll have to admit when you or your chapter has made a mistake. Own it. They’ll respect you for it later.
7) We suck at
providing a good product.
If you've ever had your car washed or gotten a cup of coffee, you know the value of good service. We need to step up and recognize that we as fraternal organizations are developmental service providers. People don’t buy crappy products, and people don’t stay members of organizations that don’t make them better.
If you've ever had your car washed or gotten a cup of coffee, you know the value of good service. We need to step up and recognize that we as fraternal organizations are developmental service providers. People don’t buy crappy products, and people don’t stay members of organizations that don’t make them better.
6) We lie.
This one seems so simple, but we are so guilty of it. And we often tell new members to expect things that we don’t provide. It’s not because we intend to lie but because we don’t even know our own chapter well enough to know what we provide.
This one seems so simple, but we are so guilty of it. And we often tell new members to expect things that we don’t provide. It’s not because we intend to lie but because we don’t even know our own chapter well enough to know what we provide.
5) We don’t invest in
them.
Listen. Engage. Make your new members just as important as you would your best friends in your organization. It’s not their duty to come to you. They’re new and learning the ropes. You know what your organization is about. Share it with them.
Listen. Engage. Make your new members just as important as you would your best friends in your organization. It’s not their duty to come to you. They’re new and learning the ropes. You know what your organization is about. Share it with them.
4) We focus on their
memories instead of their minds.
How many member ed programs do you know require rote memorization of specific words, phrases or historical info? How many of you provoke engaging conversation and critical discussion about the purpose of our organizations?
How many member ed programs do you know require rote memorization of specific words, phrases or historical info? How many of you provoke engaging conversation and critical discussion about the purpose of our organizations?
3) We reward having
their priorities out of whack.
Ever slapped a guilt trip on a new member for skipping an organizational function to study? We have. And we've also watched several new members learn over time to set the wrong priorities for their time.
Ever slapped a guilt trip on a new member for skipping an organizational function to study? We have. And we've also watched several new members learn over time to set the wrong priorities for their time.
2) We set bad examples.
Your behavior is the loudest message of “who we are,” and it’s the strongest impression that sets up your new members’ experiences in the organization. Be mindful of how you share negativity and positivity through your actions. Both attitudes are contagious.
1) We didn’t share our values with them.
This one sounds similar to #2, but it has a unique additional component: understanding why. Sit down with your new members and discuss the “why” of your members’ actions and how those individual actions relate to the organization’s Ritual. Don’t worry about saying certain words you’re not supposed to. Be open, honest, genuine, and vulnerable.
So there you have it. We strongly recommend that you don’t hide these. Let them drive a conversation about the culture of your chapter. Post the list in your meeting room. Send it out to all of your members. Tape it to your best friend’s door. But use it to critically evaluate what you’re doing to enable unnecessary struggle and conflict within your new members.

No comments:
Post a Comment